Understanding withholding tax in the Netherlands – a deep dive for investors

author: Maciej Wawrzyniak30 April 2024
Oceń post
Is tax return in the Netherlands mandatory

The Netherlands has historically been viewed as a favorable location for international finance and licensing operations due to its lenient tax policies, especially concerning interest and royalty payments. However, recent legislative changes have introduced a new withholding tax regime aimed at combating tax avoidance and preserving the Dutch tax base. This blog post delves into the details of the new withholding tax system, its implications, and the actions businesses might need to consider.

Dutch withholding tax – historical context and rationale for change

The Netherlands has long been recognized as a pivotal hub in the global financial and corporate services industry, largely due to its favorable tax regime and sophisticated financial infrastructure. Traditionally, the country did not impose withholding taxes on interest and royalty payments, which positioned it as an exceptionally attractive jurisdiction for multinational corporations seeking to optimize their tax strategies. This leniency facilitated a vast amount of international transactions through Dutch entities, exploiting the absence of withholding tax to reduce overall tax liabilities by channeling funds through the Netherlands to low-tax jurisdictions.

This practice was particularly advantageous under the international tax framework that previously allowed earnings to move almost seamlessly across borders with minimal tax friction. Companies set up sophisticated structures involving Dutch holding or finance companies to route their earnings through the Netherlands and then onto jurisdictions with lower or no taxes on received interest and royalties.

Rationale for Change

However, this model came under increasing scrutiny as global attitudes towards tax planning shifted. International bodies, including the OECD and the EU, began to push for greater transparency and fair tax competition. These changes were part of broader efforts to combat Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS), where profits are shifted away from where the actual economic activity and value creation occur to jurisdictions with more favorable tax treatments.

The Dutch government's decision to implement a withholding tax on interest and royalty payments starting in 2021 was a direct response to these international pressures. The primary aim was to dismantle the attractiveness of the Netherlands as a gateway for tax avoidance through the rerouting of payments to low-tax jurisdictions (LTJs). The move was intended to realign the Dutch tax policy with global norms that increasingly favor substance over form and economic activity over mere fiscal optimization.

Banner angielski aangifte

Scope and applicability of the new Netherlands withholding Tax

The recent overhaul of the Dutch tax regime, particularly concerning withholding taxes on interest and royalty payments, marks a significant shift in how the Netherlands manages its international tax affairs. This new withholding tax regime, instituted to combat tax avoidance, strategically targets certain types of corporate transactions while consciously avoiding an undue burden on individual taxpayers.

Detailed scope of the new withholding tax

The new withholding tax is specifically designed to address vulnerabilities in the Dutch tax system that have historically allowed for tax base erosion. It is applicable to interest and royalty payments made by Dutch entities to affiliated entities that are either located in low-tax jurisdictions (LTJs) or are classified as hybrid or reverse hybrid entities. This precise targeting is part of a broader strategy to close loopholes that have been exploited in the past.

Entities located in jurisdictions classified by the Dutch Ministry of Finance as LTJs are particularly affected by this tax. These jurisdictions typically have a significantly lower tax rate compared to the Netherlands, and they may lack the robust tax treaty network that the Netherlands maintains with other countries. By applying withholding taxes to payments sent to these LTJs, the Dutch government aims to disincentivize the use of these jurisdictions for the sole purpose of tax avoidance.

Dutch withholding tax on dividends

In a significant move to tighten its tax regime, the Netherlands introduced a conditional withholding tax on dividends beginning in 2024. This tax is levied at the standard domestic withholding tax rate, currently set at 25.8%. The introduction of this tax aims to align the country's tax system with international efforts to curb tax avoidance and ensure that dividends paid to entities in low-tax jurisdictions or through hybrid structures are taxed appropriately.

Netherlands tax on dividends has exemptions and specific refund procedures to prevent double taxation and undue burden on legitimate business operations. Exemptions typically apply to entities within the European Union or in countries that have a double taxation agreement with the Netherlands, provided these entities meet certain conditions related to substance and ownership. Refund procedures are available for entities that may have been taxed in error or where taxation exceeds the amount stipulated by applicable tax treaties, ensuring fairness and adherence to international tax norms.

Interest withholding tax in Netherlands

The new withholding tax on interest payments is applied conditionally, targeting payments made to affiliated entities in low-tax jurisdictions or to hybrid entities that may exploit differences in national tax rules to avoid taxation. Exceptions and limitations to this tax include cases where the beneficial owner of the interest is located in a jurisdiction that has a comprehensive tax treaty with the Netherlands, or where the payments are made for genuine economic activities reflected by real economic substance in the jurisdiction of the recipient.

Withholding tax on royalties

The approach to taxing royalty payments in the Netherlands has also undergone significant changes. Like interest payments, royalties were historically not subject to withholding tax, benefiting from the Netherlands' favorable tax regime. The recent reforms have introduced a conditional withholding tax on royalty payments to counteract the use of Dutch entities as pass-through vehicles for shifting profits to low-tax jurisdictions.

The new withholding tax on royalties is designed to apply under conditions similar to those for interest payments, primarily when royalties are paid to affiliated entities in low-tax jurisdictions or through hybrid arrangements. There are specific exceptions and limitations, such as for payments made to entities in countries with which the Netherlands has effective tax treaties and where the payment aligns with substantial economic activities conducted by the recipient.

These changes reflect a deliberate policy shift towards greater tax transparency and the prevention of base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) through the Netherlands. Entities involved in cross-border payments must now navigate these new regulations carefully to ensure compliance and optimize their tax positions in light of the changing global tax landscape.

Identifying Low-Tax Jurisdictions (LTJs)

The Dutch Ministry of Finance plays a critical role in the implementation of withholding taxes by annually identifying and publishing a list of low-tax jurisdictions (LTJs). This list includes countries known for their significantly lower tax rates compared to the Netherlands, such as Anguilla, the Bahamas, and Bermuda. The criteria for classifying these LTJs involve assessing the nominal corporate tax rates, which are typically set at a threshold significantly below the Dutch rate.

The inclusion of a jurisdiction on this list triggers the application of withholding taxes on payments made to entities situated in these regions. The purpose of this measure is to mitigate the risk of profit shifting to these LTJs, which could potentially erode the Dutch tax base. This approach reflects a broader trend in international tax policy aimed at increasing transparency and fairness while discouraging the use of tax havens for avoiding taxation.

Treatment of Hybrid Entities

The complexities of the international corporate tax landscape are further addressed through the Netherlands' tax rules concerning hybrid entities. These entities, due to their different tax characterizations in various jurisdictions, can create mismatches in tax outcomes, such as double deductions or double non-taxation. The Dutch tax rules strive to rectify these disparities by imposing withholding taxes on payments to these entities under certain conditions.

However, there are specific exemptions designed to prevent unjust taxation. If a hybrid entity is recognized as tax-transparent in the jurisdiction of the participants' residence, and these participants would not be subject to Dutch withholding tax if they received the income directly, the payments are exempt from withholding taxes. This exemption prevents economic double taxation and supports the principles of equity and fairness in taxation.

Economic Substance Requirements

In conjunction with the rules on LTJs and hybrid entities, the Netherlands enforces stringent economic substance requirements to counteract artificial tax arrangements. These requirements are pivotal in distinguishing genuine economic activities from those constructed merely for tax benefits. The criteria for economic substance include maintaining adequate office space, sufficient staff, and meeting a minimum payroll threshold within the Netherlands.

Entities that meet these substance requirements demonstrate real economic engagement in the Netherlands, thus legitimizing their operations beyond mere fiscal representation. This substantiation makes it significantly more challenging for the Dutch tax authorities to argue that an arrangement is artificial solely designed to evade taxes. Compliance with these substance requirements is crucial for entities to benefit from tax treaty protections and to avoid the imposition of additional Dutch taxes.

Withholding Tax and tax return in the Netherlands

In the Netherlands, the concept of withholding tax plays a crucial role in the preliminary collection of taxes on certain types of income, such as interest, dividends, and royalties. This tax is deducted at the source, meaning that it is withheld and remitted to the Dutch tax authorities by the payer, rather than the recipient of the income. This system ensures that tax on such income is collected efficiently and helps prevent tax evasion, particularly in cross-border transactions.

For taxpayers in the Netherlands, the withholding tax acts as an advance payment towards their total tax liability. When filing an annual tax return, these preliminary taxes are accounted for; taxpayers can claim a credit for any withholding tax already paid. If the withholding tax exceeds the taxpayer's total tax liability, they may be eligible for a refund. This mechanism of immediate tax collection at the source, followed by reconciliation during the annual tax return process, simplifies and secures tax revenue, aligning with both national and international tax compliance standards. This method is particularly significant in regulating transactions involving foreign entities and combating tax base erosion through the use of low-tax jurisdictions or complex corporate structures. To calculate the tax from the Netherlands, use our Dutch tax refund calculator online – you will make all the calculations, taking into account the withholding tax!